ACTION ALERT! HELP PROTECT CARNEGIE SVRA!
California State Parks is Reopening Environmental Review for the General Plan Update.
We Need Your Voice to Keep Carnegie Open for OHV Recreation!
COMMENT DEADLINE: OCTOBER 19, 2026, AT 5:00 PM
(Comment letter template below…)
Carnegie State Vehicular Recreation Area (SVRA) is facing another round of environmental review, and your comments can help protect the future of OHV recreation at Carnegie!
California State Parks is preparing a Partially Recirculated Environmental Impact Report (EIR) for Carnegie's General Plan Update. This review is focused on evaluating additional alternatives to reduce potential air quality impacts.
Cal4Wheel supports responsible environmental stewardship. However, protecting air quality should not mean eliminating riding opportunities, restricting access, or compromising the future of Carnegie SVRA. There are practical ways to measure and manage dust without closing trails or reducing recreation.
We need OHV enthusiasts to tell State Parks to consider those alternatives!
How Did We Get Here?
Carnegie has faced years of litigation involving neighboring Connolly Ranch, which has challenged activities at the SVRA.
In an earlier lawsuit filed in 2016, Connolly Ranch alleged that Carnegie operations interfered with its property rights through conditions including noise, dust, erosion, and sediment. Following a jury trial, Connolly failed to establish the substantial interference necessary for its private nuisance claim. Although the jury found a contractual breach, it found no resulting harm to the Ranch. Connolly appealed, but in May 2023, the California Court of Appeal upheld the judgment against the Ranch.
That ruling did not establish that Carnegie causes no environmental impacts. It did, however, reject important claims that Connolly had made against State Parks.
In October 2024, the Off-Highway Motor Vehicle Recreation Commission approved Carnegie's updated General Plan and Final EIR. Connolly Ranch challenged that approval in court.
On March 10, 2026, the Sacramento Superior Court ruled that the EIR had not evaluated a reasonable range of alternatives under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). The court rejected Connolly's other grounds for challenging the EIR.
State Parks subsequently rescinded the 2024 approval to comply with the ruling.
Importantly, the court did not order Carnegie to close, reduce riding acreage, or restrict OHV recreation. It required State Parks to evaluate additional alternatives. The current review is limited to alternatives that could reduce significant air quality impacts.
Alleged Air Quality Impacts Are Not the Same as Demonstrated Harm
The original EIR estimated that future Carnegie operations could generate approximately 15.87 tons of PM10 particulate matter annually, slightly exceeding the applicable 15-ton significance threshold.
PM10 refers to airborne particles, including dust, small enough to be inhaled.
But there is an important difference between computer-modeled emissions and actual air pollution measured at neighboring properties.
The environmental review does not establish, through site-specific monitoring and source attribution, that Carnegie's OHV activities have historically caused or currently cause harmful particulate concentrations at Connolly Ranch.
That does not mean air quality should be ignored. It means decisions affecting public recreation should be based on reliable evidence, not assumptions.
And here's something worth considering: the modeled PM10 exceedance is only 0.87 tons annually. That raises an obvious question. Could targeted dust-control improvements eliminate the exceedance without restricting OHV recreation?
Cal4Wheel believes State Parks should thoroughly evaluate that possibility.
Better Alternatives Exist. Let's Put Them on the Record!
Cal4Wheel is recommending that State Parks evaluate a Full OHV Recreation Preservation and Enhanced Air Quality Management Alternative.
Instead of restricting recreation, this alternative would focus on:
- Measuring actual air quality: Install monitoring equipment at representative locations within and near Carnegie to determine existing particulate concentrations.
- Identifying where dust originates: Distinguish OHV-generated dust from regional background pollution, road traffic, agricultural activity, and other sources.
- Improving emissions estimates: Update outdated visitor and vehicle-use information and verify that dust calculations accurately represent Carnegie's terrain and riding conditions.
- Reducing dust without closing trails: Evaluate improved dust suppression, appropriate surface stabilization in staging and parking areas, maintenance improvements, and cleaner park equipment.
- Monitoring results: Establish measurable air quality goals and regularly evaluate whether dust-control measures are working.
- Protecting recreation: Preserve existing authorized riding areas, trails, vehicle classes, operating hours, events, and opportunities for future improvements.
These measures should be evaluated for their effectiveness, cost, and feasibility. Their benefits should be compared against any proposed alternative that restricts public recreation.
Carnegie exists to provide OHV recreation. Environmental management should help sustain that purpose, not undermine it.
TAKE ACTION! SUBMIT YOUR COMMENTS BY OCTOBER 19!
Email: planning@parks.ca.gov
Subject: Carnegie SVRA General Plan Update – Scoping Comments
You can review the project documents on the California State Parks Carnegie General Plan Update webpage.
Use the customizable letter below. Please personalize it! Tell State Parks why Carnegie matters to you, how you use the park, and why protecting its future is important.
You don't need to be an environmental scientist to make your voice count!
CUSTOMIZABLE COMMENT LETTER
To: California State Parks, OHMVR Division
Email: planning@parks.ca.gov
Subject: Carnegie SVRA General Plan Update – Scoping Comments
Dear California State Parks:
I am submitting comments regarding the Partially Recirculated Environmental Impact Report for the Carnegie State Vehicular Recreation Area General Plan Update.
I strongly support protecting all existing authorized OHV recreation at Carnegie, including its riding areas, trails, operating hours, events, and facilities. I also support maintaining opportunities for future improvements and ensuring Carnegie remains a viable OHV recreation destination for generations to come.
[PERSONALIZE: Describe your experience at Carnegie. How long have you been riding there? What activities, trails, or events do you enjoy? Why is Carnegie important to you or your family? If you have not yet recreated at Carnegie, share about your desire to go and what type of riding you plan to do.]
In the revised Environmental Impact Report, I urge CA State Parks to include the following items within the additional alternative(s) that are drafted:
- Require Accurate Air Quality Information
The previous EIR identified potentially significant PM10 emissions based on computer modeling. However, it did not establish through site-specific monitoring that Carnegie's OHV activities cause harmful particulate concentrations at neighboring properties. I request that State Parks evaluate alternatives incorporating actual air quality monitoring, updated emissions calculations, and methods to distinguish Carnegie-generated dust from other pollution sources.
[OPTIONAL: Share observations about dust, weather, riding conditions, or air quality at Carnegie.]
- Evaluate Dust-Control Measures Before Restricting Recreation
The previous EIR estimated annual PM10 emissions of approximately 15.87 tons, compared with a significance threshold of 15 tons. I request that State Parks evaluate whether feasible dust-control improvements can eliminate this relatively small modeled exceedance. Potential measures include improved dust suppression in developed areas, stabilization of parking and staging surfaces, better maintenance practices, and cleaner park equipment. These improvements should preserve existing riding terrain and recreational opportunities.
[OPTIONAL: Suggest practical improvements you believe would help reduce dust without affecting riding.]
- Include an Alternative That Fully Preserves OHV Recreation
I specifically request that State Parks evaluate a Full OHV Recreation Preservation and Enhanced Air Quality Management Alternative. This alternative should maintain all existing authorized riding opportunities, vehicle classes, operating schedules, visitor capacity, events, and facilities while evaluating feasible air quality improvements. It should also preserve the ability to maintain and improve Carnegie's recreational facilities in the future.
- Establish Monitoring and Management Based on Actual Conditions
I support a reasonable air quality monitoring program with measurable goals, transparent reporting, and targeted corrective measures when necessary. Environmental management decisions should be based on reliable data and demonstrated effectiveness. Permanent closures, attendance limits, and other restrictions should not be presumed necessary when less restrictive measures could achieve comparable environmental benefits.
- Consider the Consequences of Reduced OHV Access
Restricting Carnegie could force recreationists to travel farther to other riding destinations, potentially increasing vehicle emissions and placing additional pressure on other recreation areas. State Parks should evaluate these consequences when comparing alternatives.
[PERSONALIZE: Explain how restrictions at Carnegie would affect you, your family, your club, or your community. Would you have to travel farther to ride?]
I urge California State Parks to protect Carnegie's existing OHV recreation opportunities while evaluating reasonable, effective air quality improvements.
Please include an alternative that emphasizes accurate measurement, monitoring, targeted dust mitigation, and long-term environmental management without reducing existing OHV access or compromising the future of Carnegie SVRA.
Thank you for considering my comments.
Sincerely,
[Your Name]
[City, State]
[OHV Club or Organization, if applicable]
DON'T WAIT! COMMENTS CLOSE OCTOBER 19 AT 5:00 PM!
Send your personalized letter to planning@parks.ca.gov
Protect Carnegie. Protect Our Trails. Protect the Future of OHV Recreation!
Access Menu
Tags
- 30x30
- ASA
- American Sand Association
- Coyote Creek Agrivoltaic Ranch Project
- Hungry Valley SVRA
- Land Use
- NRC Report
- Ocotillo Weills SVRA
- Prairie City SVRA
- action alert
- blm
- california state parks
- carnegie svra
- comment letters
- eldorado national forest
- endangered species
- endangered species act
- foothill yellow legged frog
- forest plan revisions
- johnson valley
- legislation
- litigation
- moab
- oceano dunes svra
- oceano svra
- ohmvr commission
- red rock canyon
- sequoia national forest
- sierra national forest
- stanislaus national forest