Skip to main content

ACTION ALERT: Rescind the BLM’s Conservation & Landscape Health Rule

| Rose Winn, Cal4wheel Natural Resources Consultant | Access Issues

 

The Bureau of Land Management (BLM) has proposed rescind the Conservation and Landscape Health Rule (CLHR). When the CLHR was passed in 2024, the BLM claimed they had discovered that secret statutory authority had been hiding in plain sight for 50 years (in the 1976 Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA)) that allows them to create and sell conservation leases on the 247 million acres of public land managed by the BLM across the USA. This was a categorically false claim, which Cal4Wheel called out in our public comments at that time. Leadership of the BLM has since shifted, and the current proposal to Rescind has been advanced to correct the egregious error that was made through passage of the CLHR.

The BLM now acknowledges that the 2024 CLHR is unnecessary and violates existing statutory requirements. Among other things, the 2024 Rule is unnecessary to facilitate, and even undermines, the BLM's management of the public lands under applicable law. It constrains agency flexibility that is necessary to manage BLM public land under principles of multiple use and sustain yield, which is explicitly directed by the Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA). For these and additional reasons the BLM has proposed to rescind the 2024 Rule in full and is requesting public comment on the proposal.

It is critical for Californians to note that 15.3% of all land within California is managed by the BLM. This means that under the 2024 CLHR, 16+ million acres of California’s public land is up for grabs to be leased to private parties and stripped away from public access! Through the CLHR lease program, the highest bidder possesses the authority to ban any/all uses and public access to the leased acreage they are paying for. The leases are intended to be written as permanent contracts – thus once a class of use or access is banned, that leased public land will NEVER be restored, unless the lease holder chose to change their management protocol.

The CLHR is problematic on multiple levels and should be rescinded:

  • The BLM does not have the authority to create this rule. FLPMA does not permit a conservation lease scheme; if Congress wanted the BLM to administer such a program, they would have expressly authorized it. By selling leases the BLM is raising revenue for the government, which the BLM does not have authority to do. Only Congress can authorize a new program to raise revenue for the government.
  • The CLHR was unnecessary: the BLM is already required to comply with dozens of other laws and executive orders to prioritize conservation on public lands. Scores of environmental lawsuits that get filed every year ensure that compliance with these laws is taken seriously. Despite the statutory requirement the BLM has to manage public lands for multiple use, conservation is already prioritized above all other uses on a regular basis.
  • The CLHR is rooted in the 30x30 agenda by requiring the BLM to take a “precautionary approach” when authorizing land uses that may impair “ecosystem resilience.” Given that the CLHR was based, in part, on Biden’s 30x30 and climate change Executive Orders (EO), including EO14008, it has become evident that the underlying premise of the CLHR is that nearly everything impairs “ecosystem resilience” and contributes to climate change. EO14008 opines that only land in its “natural state” meets the 30x30 requirements, and protection of the natural state is achieved through limited to zero human use of multiple use lands. EO-14008 has since been repealed by President Trump - subsequently, the CLHR is not only illegal, it is now void of any farce of validity the BLM claimed under their self-imposed obligation to pass the Rule to align with EO-14008.
  • The CLHR implemented Landscape Health Standards that have created confusion and chaos in the BLM permitting process for organized and casual recreational use of BLM lands. Agency staff have limited time to authorize permitted OHV events or complete travel plans due to the added bureaucratic sludge created by Landscape Health Standards.
  • The CLHR has led to foreign intervention in public land management. The opportunity to lease BLM land has been opened to both American and foreign entities. Americans are already facing ongoing threats and sabotage of our agriculture and energy industries by Brazilian, Chinese, and other foreign corporations and governments. Opening our public lands to be leased and controlled by foreign entities is a serious and completely unnecessary increased risk to our national security.

As public land access advocates, one of our chief concerns is that the CLHR can be used to limit motorized recreation, dispersed camping, and other forms of outdoor recreation on public lands. The CLHR provides a new way for conservation organizations to create de facto wilderness where they have previously failed to get Congress to make wilderness designations. The $800 billion outdoor recreation industry historically has thrived because of the BLM’s careful efforts to balance conservation with other uses. By prioritizing conservation even more than it already is, the CLHR undermines an industry that is fueling the livelihoods of tens of millions of citizens who live in the West.

You can join the effort to oppose the BLM Rule! Public comments will be accepted until November 10.

Submit an individual comment to the BLM (feel free to use the sample letter below):

  1. Go to: Federal Register :: Conservation and Landscape Health
  2. Click on the blue “Comment” button

AA-blmclhr-fig1.png

 

You can also submit a comment on behalf of your OHV club (use the same information as noted above) – and get 3 or more of your friends and fellow OHV enthusiasts to submit an individual comment!

 

Sample letter (you can tailor this to fit your interests and experience, see suggestions below):

Subject line: I urge you to RESCIND the Conservation and Landscape Health Rule

Department of the Interior and Bureau of Land Management,

I am a recreation enthusiast who is passionate about continuing responsible recreational access to federal lands. I am writing to urge the BLM to rescind the 2024 Conservation and Landscape Health Rule.

This Rule redefines “Conservation” as a unique protected use, and treats “Conservation” as a use just like recreation and other uses that are outlined in the Federal Land Policy and Management Act of 1976 (FLPMA). This change is not appropriate to be implemented through a rulemaking process but should have instead been considered by Congress. 

[Note something about you or your family’s history and love for OHV recreation (and/or other outdoor recreation), why BLM-managed public land provides high-value recreation sites for you, what activities or events you engage in on BLM-managed land, how OHV and/or outdoor recreation benefit your physical, mental, and spiritual health, how OHV and/or outdoor recreation allow you to have meaningful connections with your family and friends and build up your sense of community with others.]

The Rule also implements Landscape Health Standards across all BLM managed public lands instead of applying it only to grazing. This creates a vague, first-of-its-kind Conservation Leasing scheme, and creates new categories of lands that can be designated as Areas of Critical Environmental Concern. The impact of this Rule is far too much to be implemented through a single rulemaking. Even the authors of this Rule cannot credibly claim to understand how all these sweeping changes interact since the rule was implemented.

[Use the talking points above to cite your concerns here, or add in other points from your own research and perspective.]

As a concerned citizen and avid user of BLM public lands, I urge the BLM to RESCIND the Conservation and Landscape Health Rule

Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely,

[your name]

Details you may consider adding to tailor your letter:

  • Note the BLM lands where you enjoy recreating (IE: Clear Creek, Cow Mountain, Jawbone, Johnson Valley, find all California BLM OHV areas via this link).
  • The BLM is already required to prioritize conservation through compliance with dozens of other laws and regulations (including those listed below) – additional constraints that remove multiple use management for conservation is neither necessary, nor beneficial to the American people.
    • Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA)
    • Multiple-Use Sustained-Yield Act
    • National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA)
    • National Forest Management Act
    • Endangered Species Act
    • Clean Water Act
    • Clean Air Act
    • Wilderness Act
    • National Wildlife Refuge System Administration Act
    • Fish and Wildlife Coordination Act
    • Migratory Bird Treaty Act
    • Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act
    • Wild and Scenic Rivers Act
    • Lacey Act
  • Share about conservation activities that you’ve observed on BLM lands where you recreate – note how this demonstrates that conservation and multiple use management are complementary rather than in conflict with one another.
  • The newly created Landscape Health Standards complicate and slow down the permitting process for recreational uses on BLM lands. Note any problems you’ve experienced with securing permits for casual recreational access or OHV events on BLM lands.
  • The BLM’s Conservation and Landscape Health Rule (Rule) authorizes the agency to sell parcels of public land in the form of restoration and mitigation leases, however, the BLM did not have the authority to create this Rule and considerations from the Recreation and Public Purposes Act further complicate the issue,
  • The Rule expands means by which the BLM may implement Areas of Critical Environmental Concern (ACECs).
  • The House Natural Resources Committee has called out the Rule as a direct attack on public access to public lands, noting that the BLM is in violation of FLPMA and the multiple-use directive by implementing this Rule
  • The language specific to how conservation leases will be managed is vague, leasees will be permitted to implement bans on various uses or forms of public access that they deem incompatible with their goals for conservation, restoration, and mitigation
  • While the Final Rule states that leases will extend for a 10-year period, the Rule does not specify whether changes to public access or bans on specific uses will extend or expire at the termination of a 10-year lease
  • The Rule was based largely on Biden’s 30x30 and climate change Executive Orders (EOs), including EO-14008. EO-14008 has since been repealed by President Trump - subsequently, the Rule is not only illegal, it is now void of any farce of validity the BLM claimed under their self-imposed obligation to pass the Rule to align with EO-14008.
  • The Rule enables the BLM to raise revenue for the government, which they are forbidden by Congress to do.
  • The Rule opens the door for foreign intervention in public land management by providing the opportunity for foreign entities to lease BLM-managed public land.

Leave a comment

You are commenting as guest.