Skip to main content

CAL4WHEEL SUBMITS COMMENTS TO NOAA ON CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION OVERREACH

| Rose Winn, Cal4wheel Natural Resources Consultant | Access Issues

 

On August 22, I submitted comments on behalf of Cal4Wheel to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) as part of its performance evaluation of the California Coastal Management Program (CCMP). Our message is straightforward: California’s coast needs strong environmental stewardship, but the California Coastal Commission (CCC) must operate within the limits of authority that are granted to it by law.

For more than 65 years, Cal4Wheel has stood for two principles that belong together: public land access and active stewardship. We believe conservation and responsible recreation can, and must, coexist. That same balance is embedded in the federal Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA), which protects environmental resources while also recognizing recreation, public access, economic activity, infrastructure, and meaningful public participation as equally legitimate coastal-management priorities.

Our concern is a decades-long pattern in which the CCC has increasingly stretched its permitting and oversight authority beyond the scope of its authority – which is isolated to coastal development review – and into decisions assigned by law to State Parks, federal public land managers, local governments, harbor districts, water agencies, and other entities.

Oceano Dunes Showcases What Is at Stake

Nowhere is that problem clearer than at Oceano Dunes SVRA.

Oceano Dunes is California’s only State Park that is legislatively designated for beach and dune OHV recreation. Today, only about two miles of California’s roughly 840-mile coastline, which equates to merely ¼ of 1%, remains available for beach OHV recreation. More than 99.7% of California’s coastline is fully and permanently closed to OHV access.

Yet in 2021, the CCC attempted to eliminate OHV recreation, substantially restrict beach camping, and close the Pier Avenue vehicle entrance to Oceano Dunes through illegal leverage of its development permitting authority. Years of litigation followed. The controversy ultimately raised fundamental questions about whether a coastal permitting agency could effectively rewrite the operation of a legislatively established State Park recreation program.

This is about far more than four-wheel drives. Oceano Dunes provides affordable camping, fishing, sightseeing, family recreation and direct coastal access, including opportunities important to people with mobility limitations who depend upon vehicle access to enjoy the beach.

The Coastal Commission’s attempts to close Oceano Dunes to OHV access relied heavily on claims that OHV recreation decimates local habitat and species of concern. Those claims could not be further from the truth… the OHV program at Oceano Dunes has actively restored habitat for wildlife across hundreds of acres, and has achieved one of the most successful species recovery programs for endangered shorebirds in the entire state… all within the boundary of a highly active OHV park. Cal4Wheel has advocated for a future in which species conservation and recreation continue to coexist through the Oceano Dunes Habitat Conservation Plan.

The Problem Goes Far Beyond Oceano Dunes

Our comments additionally addressed public access at other State Parks, federal lands, and harbors; Local Coastal Programs; as well as scientific integrity, accessibility, duplicative regulation and meaningful public participation.

We also discussed CCC efforts to forbid construction of desalination projects, calling out a specific example in the Huntington Beach desalination project. This desalination plant would have produced 50 million gallons of drinking water per day, yet the Coastal Commission’s unjustified regulatory obstacles ultimately prevented it from proceeding to construction.

For Californians facing high costs of living, recurring water conservation mandates, and long-term water-supply uncertainty… diversified water supplies matter. California’s continued dependence on imported water from the Colorado River amplifies the significance of these issues. Lack of access to locally sourced fresh water has consequences far beyond our faucets. California’s reliance on Colorado River water negatively impacts recreation and resources at Lake Mead, Lake Powell and the broader river watershed.

Desalination has environmental impacts that must be responsibly mitigated… which is achieved through rigorous science, modern technology and balanced permitting… not by treating viable desalination water infrastructure as inherently incompatible with coastal protection.

What Cal4Wheel Is Asking NOAA to Do

In our comments, Cal4Wheel is not asking NOAA to weaken conservation. We are asking NOAA to strengthen coastal governance by ensuring that the California Coastal Management Program and the California Coastal Commission:

·        operate within the limits of legal jurisdictional boundaries,

·        respect other public-land agencies,

·        demand credible science,

·        prioritize mitigation before closure,

·        protect affordable and accessible recreation,

·        reduce duplicative regulation,

·        and ensure the public can genuinely influence decisions that impact our public lands and waters.

California’s beaches and coastal waters belong to all Californians. Protecting them and keeping them meaningfully accessible are not competing goals. Responsible stewardship requires both.

Read the full Cal4Wheel comment letter to NOAA here

 

 

Leave a comment

You are commenting as guest.