Natural Resources Report for July-September 2026
OHMVR COMMISSION TOUR OF SIERRA TREK
On August 7, Cal4Wheel hosted the OHMVR Commission on a tour of Sierra Trek. The day included discussions with Cal4Wheel’s Sierra Trek event leadership, law enforcement personnel who actively support Trek, vendors, and public land access advocates among Cal4Wheel’s board and membership. I hosted a segment focused on Cal4Wheel’s public land stewardship history and impact, emphasizing the need for collaboration between our OHV user community and agencies like State Parks, the Forest Service, and law enforcement. This tour provided Cal4Wheel a valuable platform to showcase our 65+ year dedication to responsible OHV recreation, public land stewardship and restoration, and OHV safety.

John Allen shared about the long history of local Cal4Wheel collaboration with Tahoe National Forest, and highlighted the recently completed bathroom installation project on the Barrett Lake Trail. We also took the full group out to the Fordyce Trail to experience Trek in action. The OHMVR Commission and other CA State Parks staff who attended all shared a ton of positive feedback about the tour. Many shared that while they had some knowledge of Cal4Wheel’s advocacy, they had a new understanding of the depth of our work, most notably the impact and necessity of our mission. Through this tour, we expanded our working relationships with the OHMVR Commission and State Parks staff. Several of them also expressed interest in joining in a future Cal4Wheel event! The tour and the follow up conversations that have resulted from it since were a grand success.

Many thanks to Roger Salazar for initiating the tour idea and leading planning for the OHMVR Commission over the last year. And a round of applause and massive gratitude is due to John & Rene Allen, who led all of the planning, coordinating, and hosting of the tour for Cal4Wheel – they turned a general concept into a fun and high-impact event! Thank you, John & Rene!
TRAIL STEWARDSHIP IN SIERRA NATIONAL FOREST
On July 29, I was thrilled to get to make Sierra National Forest my office for the day doing trail work with Stewards of the Sierra National Forest on behalf of Cal4Wheel. The Stewards are among the most impactful volunteer group putting in the sweat equity to keep our trails open in the Sierra. It was an honor to work alongside them in the field.

I’ve had the joy of collaborating for Cal4Wheel with Steve Cowdrey and Stewards leadership on multiple NEPA projects and grants over the years. Steve’s knowledge of the full forest terrain and local administrative nuances has been a tremendous asset that has helped protect hundreds of miles of routes from closures and restrictions.
The trail work we completed included removing logs and debris from roads and trails, putting signs up on unmarked designated routes, and repairing damaged signs. It’s unglamorous tedium at times, but essential. Unsigned routes often get passed up for Forest Service maintenance, overgrowth quickly makes the route impassable, then the routes are “decommissioned” - IE: permanently closed.


The Stewards work primarily in the Bass Lake Ranger District of the Sierra National Forest, and their work is even more critically important now since the 2020 Creek Fire, which consumed 380,000 acres. Miles upon miles upon miles of roads and trails are surrounded by scorched earth burn scar for as far as the eye can see. The vegetation that has regrown beneath the charred toothpicks of tree carcasses is solely white thorn and scrub brush, which takes over every square inch of open dirt and chokes out the possibility for pines and conifers to reseed and grow naturally. There are years of burn scar rehab and forest restoration needed… the Stewards work to keep roads open in this region will ensure that access remains for restoration to occur if / when it is finally approved and funded by the Forest Service (and not halted by lawsuits from anti-access groups).
Keeping roads and trails open for motorized access is what keeps the forest open for everyone to enjoy. Hikers, campers, horseback riders, hunters, anglers, mountain bikers, dirt bike riders, photographers, star gazers, foragers, birders, white water rafters, rock climbers… all reach their destinations on publicly accessible roads and trails. The Stewards work is what keeps our public lands open for access for all!
There is far more trail work to be done than current volunteer commitments can address. If you would like to volunteer some time to help - whether that’s once a week, once a month, or once a year - it is needed! Please reach out and I’ll gladly help you find a way for you to get involved in the Sierra National Forest, or any other national forest in your neck of the woods, through whatever timeframe and capacity you have available.
CAL4WHEEL CONTINUES THE FIGHT TO SAVE LAKE PILLSBURY
Lake Pillsbury may not immediately come to mind when we talk about threats to OHV access, but what happens to this lake could have a lasting impact on recreation throughout the Mendocino National Forest.

In September, I submitted a second comment letter on behalf of Cal4Wheel to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), opposing the proposed destruction of Scott Dam and elimination of Lake Pillsbury. This was a special extended scoping comment period, giving us another opportunity to build on the comments I originally submitted to FERC on December 19, 2025.
Our position remains clear: Scott Dam should not be destroyed, and Lake Pillsbury should be preserved.
Lake Pillsbury is the largest lake in the Mendocino National Forest, covering 2,280 acres with about 31 miles of shoreline. It is much more than a reservoir. It is a recreation hub for camping, four-wheeling, OHV riding, hunting, fishing, boating, hiking and backcountry exploration. For our members, the connection to motorized recreation is especially important.
The Upper Lake Ranger District provides more than 135 miles of designated OHV system trails and roads, including 33 miles of trails in the Lake Pillsbury basin, many of which are four-wheel-drive trails. The M1 corridor north of the lake and its connecting routes provide access for four-wheel-drive touring, dispersed camping, trailheads and travel throughout this part of the forest. Take the lake away, and those trails do not technically disappear overnight. But recreation does not work that way.
Lake Pillsbury is the destination that brings people into this part of the forest. Families camp near the lake and spend several days exploring the surrounding roads and trails. OHV users stage from the area. Four-wheelers combine trail riding with fishing, camping, hunting and sightseeing. Eliminating the lake changes the entire recreation experience and removes the anchor that supports multi-day use of the surrounding trail network.
There is another problem that FERC needs to address: where do all those people go?
Closing a recreation destination does not make recreation demand disappear. Visitors will be pushed toward other campgrounds, trails and dispersed recreation areas in the Mendocino National Forest, Lake Mendocino, the Russian River and elsewhere. For OHV recreation, this problem is amplified because we cannot simply move onto another piece of public land. Motorized use is restricted to designated roads, trails and areas. Concentrating more visitors onto an already finite trail system can mean additional crowding, maintenance demands, user conflicts and pressure for future restrictions.
Our September comments therefore asked FERC to prepare a full Environmental Impact Statement and look beyond the physical act of tearing down Scott Dam. We asked the agency to analyze the real impacts to recreation and OHV access, developed and dispersed camping, surrounding roads and trails, local businesses, agriculture and water supply, wildlife habitat, sediment and water quality, and wildfire response. We also called for a serious analysis of the No Action Alternative and other options that could preserve the lake, including transfer to another operator, rehabilitation, seismic improvements and modified operations.
Wildfire is another major concern. Lake Pillsbury provides a large, immediately available water source in remote, heavily forested country where minutes matter during initial attack. Eliminating that resource deserves far more scrutiny than simply assuming another water source will be available when firefighters need it.
This is ultimately about protecting an entire public-land recreation landscape, not simply saving a body of water.
Cal4Wheel has been advocating for OHV recreation on public lands since 1959. Sometimes protecting a trail means fighting a closure directly. Other times it means recognizing a threat several steps before the gate gets locked. Lake Pillsbury is one of those fights.
We will continue advocating for FERC to fully account for what Northern California stands to lose before anyone makes the irreversible decision to destroy Scott Dam and drain Lake Pillsbury.
Click here to read the September 2026 and December 2025 Cal4Wheel letters to FERC: https://bit.ly/Save-Lake-Pillsbury
CAL4WHEEL SUPPORTS LONG OVERDUE REFORM OF THE
FOREST SERVICE TRAVEL MANAGEMENT RULE
I recently submitted comments on behalf of Cal4Wheel supporting the USDA Forest Service’s proposed revisions to the Travel Management Rule. The existing closed-unless-designated system has operated like a one-way ratchet: routes can be omitted or closed through one planning decision, while reopening them may require years of environmental review, funding and litigation. California has experienced these consequences throughout our 18 National Forests. Travel planning has eliminated route mileage, fragmented loops, restricted vehicle classes, isolated destinations and reduced alternate access needed during wildfires, washouts, snow damage and restoration work.

Anti-access groups have falsely characterized the proposed open-unless-closed approach as authorization for uncontrolled cross-country travel. The revisions would not allow new routes through undisturbed land, open Wilderness to vehicles or eliminate environmental review, seasonal restrictions, emergency closures or public-safety authority. Existing Motor Vehicle Use Maps would remain operative during implementation. The Forest Service would simply need lawful, site-specific justification before closing or materially restricting an existing access feature.
Our comment letter also supports removal of the former minimization criteria, replacement of the minimum-road-system concept with an adequate and functional transportation network, annual review of closures, improved mapping, a public route-nomination process and recognition of volunteer maintenance capacity.
We further requested alignment with the Outdoor Americans with Disabilities Act, including evaluation of its benchmark of 2.5 miles of authorized motorized road per square mile and comparable replacement access when closure is unavoidable.
Cal4Wheel is not asking the Forest Service to ignore resource damage or public-safety hazards. We are asking it to manage actual problems instead of automatically managing people out. These proposed revisions offer a rare opportunity to restore balance, local judgment and common sense to national forest travel management. Cal4Wheel supports that effort, and we will remain actively involved as the environmental review and rulemaking proceed.
Click here to read the full Cal4Wheel comment letter on the Travel Management Rule proposed revisions: https://bit.ly/Forest-Service-Travel-Management-Rule
CAL4WHEEL SUBMITS COMMENTS TO NOAA ON
CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION OVERREACH
On August 22, I submitted comments on behalf of Cal4Wheel to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) as part of its performance evaluation of the California Coastal Management Program (CCMP). Our message is straightforward: California’s coast needs strong environmental stewardship, but the California Coastal Commission (CCC) must operate within the limits of authority that are granted to it by law.

For more than 65 years, Cal4Wheel has stood for two principles that belong together: public land access and active stewardship. We believe conservation and responsible recreation can, and must, coexist. That same balance is embedded in the federal Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA), which protects environmental resources while also recognizing recreation, public access, economic activity, infrastructure, and meaningful public participation as equally legitimate coastal-management priorities.
Our concern is a decades-long pattern in which the CCC has increasingly stretched its permitting and oversight authority beyond the scope of its authority – which is isolated to coastal development review – and into decisions assigned by law to State Parks, federal public land managers, local governments, harbor districts, water agencies, and other entities.
Oceano Dunes Showcases What Is at Stake
Nowhere is that problem clearer than at Oceano Dunes SVRA.
Oceano Dunes is California’s only State Park that is legislatively designated for beach and dune OHV recreation. Today, only about two miles of California’s roughly 840-mile coastline, which equates to merely ¼ of 1%, remains available for beach OHV recreation. More than 99.7% of California’s coastline is fully and permanently closed to OHV access.
Yet in 2021, the CCC attempted to eliminate OHV recreation, substantially restrict beach camping, and close the Pier Avenue vehicle entrance to Oceano Dunes through illegal leverage of its development permitting authority. Years of litigation followed. The controversy ultimately raised fundamental questions about whether a coastal permitting agency could effectively rewrite the operation of a legislatively established State Park recreation program.
This is about far more than four-wheel drives. Oceano Dunes provides affordable camping, fishing, sightseeing, family recreation and direct coastal access, including opportunities important to people with mobility limitations who depend upon vehicle access to enjoy the beach.
The Coastal Commission’s attempts to close Oceano Dunes to OHV access relied heavily on claims that OHV recreation decimates local habitat and species of concern. Those claims could not be further from the truth… the OHV program at Oceano Dunes has actively restored habitat for wildlife across hundreds of acres, and has achieved one of the most successful species recovery programs for endangered shorebirds in the entire state… all within the boundary of a highly active OHV park. Cal4Wheel has advocated for a future in which species conservation and recreation continue to coexist through the Oceano Dunes Habitat Conservation Plan.
The Problem Goes Far Beyond Oceano Dunes
Our comments additionally addressed public access at other State Parks, federal lands, and harbors; Local Coastal Programs; as well as scientific integrity, accessibility, duplicative regulation and meaningful public participation.
We also discussed CCC efforts to forbid construction of desalination projects, calling out a specific example in the Huntington Beach desalination project. This desalination plant would have produced 50 million gallons of drinking water per day, yet the Coastal Commission’s unjustified regulatory obstacles ultimately prevented it from proceeding to construction.
For Californians facing high costs of living, recurring water conservation mandates, and long-term water-supply uncertainty… diversified water supplies matter. California’s continued dependence on imported water from the Colorado River amplifies the significance of these issues. Lack of access to locally sourced fresh water has consequences far beyond our faucets. California’s reliance on Colorado River water negatively impacts recreation and resources at Lake Mead, Lake Powell and the broader river watershed.
Desalination has environmental impacts that must be responsibly mitigated… which is achieved through rigorous science, modern technology and balanced permitting… not by treating viable desalination water infrastructure as inherently incompatible with coastal protection.
What Cal4Wheel Is Asking NOAA to Do
In our comments, Cal4Wheel is not asking NOAA to weaken conservation. We are asking NOAA to strengthen coastal governance by ensuring that the California Coastal Management Program and the California Coastal Commission:
- operate within the limits of legal jurisdictional boundaries,
- respect other public-land agencies,
- demand credible science,
- prioritize mitigation before closure,
- protect affordable and accessible recreation,
- reduce duplicative regulation,
- and ensure the public can genuinely influence decisions that impact our public lands and waters.
California’s beaches and coastal waters belong to all Californians. Protecting them and keeping them meaningfully accessible are not competing goals. Responsible stewardship requires both.
Read the full Cal4Wheel comment letter to NOAA here: https://bit.ly/CA-CC-Overreach
If you have questions about any of the items shared above, or if you would like to discuss issues related to public land access that are affecting your club or trails in your region, please reach out to me at rwinn@cal4nrc.com.
There is much more to report than I can fit into reasonable time and space for each report, and the issues we are facing are continually evolving! Stay informed on all of my work to protect your access to public lands in the “Access Issues” section of the Cal4Wheel website: https://cal4wheel.com/access-advocacy/access-issues.
Access Menu
Tags
- 30x30
- ASA
- American Sand Association
- Coyote Creek Agrivoltaic Ranch Project
- Hungry Valley SVRA
- Land Use
- NRC Report
- Ocotillo Weills SVRA
- Prairie City SVRA
- action alert
- blm
- california state parks
- carnegie svra
- comment letters
- eldorado national forest
- endangered species
- endangered species act
- foothill yellow legged frog
- forest plan revisions
- johnson valley
- legislation
- litigation
- moab
- oceano dunes svra
- oceano svra
- ohmvr commission
- red rock canyon
- sequoia national forest
- sierra national forest
- stanislaus national forest